Skip to content
Philadelphia Meetings

Committee on Rules, November 17, 2026

Recommends approval: Old City residential overlay core use changes, unanimous

2h 4m17,891 words
81 mentionspublic hearingcommercialoverlay districtzoningresidentialsetbackvariancemixed useindustrialland useapprovedrezoningPhiladelphia, PA
Just researching this meeting? Get free Philadelphia alerts

What happened

On November 17, 2026, the Committee on Rules recommended approval of Old City residential overlay core use changes (unanimous).

Philadelphia City Council's Committee on Rules voted unanimously (voice vote) to report favorably Bill 260855, rezoning the block bounded by Rubicam, Ashmead, Wakefield and Bringhurst Streets in Germantown/Banton Hill from RM-1 to RSA-5 (as amended), along with six other zoning a…

Meeting key facts
Jurisdiction
Philadelphia, PA
Governing body
Advisory (makes a recommendation)
Date
November 17, 2026
Decisions
8 zoning decisions
Outcome
Recommends approval, unanimous
Next step
Final board vote (pending)

Projects in this meeting (2)

Remapping RM-1 to RSA-5 bounded by Rubicam, Ashmead, Wakefield and Bri

Recommended
Area bounded by Rubicam Street, Ashmead Street, Wakefield Street and Bringhurst Street, Upper Northwest
Open this project

Tobacco sales use category and 750-ft buffer

Recommended
Open this project

Free sample: decision 1 of 8

Remapping RM-1 to RSA-5 bounded by Rubicam, Ashmead, Wakefield and Bringhurst Streets

Bill 260855 by Councilmember Bass changes portions of the block from RM-1 residential multifamily to RSA-5 residential single-family to reflect current land use; part of larger Upper Northwest remapping under review. Amendment adopted by voice vote; reported favorably as amended. Planning Commission to consider 2026-11-19.

The other decisions are listed below. Available full write-ups and conditions are included with Pro.

Get every Philadelphia meeting with full decisions, votes, and zoning details, within hours of each session.

Philadelphia access in Pro, $39/month.

Key Decisions (8)

Recommends Approval

Remapping RM-1 to RSA-5 bounded by Rubicam, Ashmead, Wakefield and Bringhurst Streets

Vote: unanimousMoved by Squilla
Recommends Approval

Tobacco sales use category and 750-ft buffer

Vote: unanimousMoved by Squilla
Recommends Approval

Retail sales use category redefinition (groceries/pharmaceuticals/convenience)

Vote: unanimousMoved by Squilla
Recommends Approval

Heritage tree removal requirements revision

Vote: unanimousMoved by Squilla
Recommends Approval

VDO Fifth District Overlay expansion - Logan Square cultural institutions

Vote: unanimous1 conditions attachedMoved by Squilla
Recommends Approval

Old City residential overlay core use changes

Vote: unanimousMoved by Squilla
Recommends Approval

Old City Special Services District 2027-2033 plan and assessment

Vote: unanimousMoved by Squilla
Tabled

Fifth District commercial business hour restrictions held

Full write-ups and conditions for all 8 decisions in Pro.

Zoning Changes (1)

Market Signals (4)

Commercial Demand

New tobacco-sales use with 750-ft buffers and special exception in…

Commercial Demand

Old City landlords cite smoke shops backfilling vacant storefronts because…

Housing Demand

Old City population has grown to about 9,000 residents with…

Other

Heritage tree removal may shift from ZBA variance to staff…

Who spoke

19 distinct speakers; 13 identified names.

All speaker roles: 1 Chair, 3 Staff, 5 Public, 6 Councilmember, 3 Witness, 1 Clerk.

Identified name roles: 1 Chair, 3 Staff, 6 Councilmember, 3 Witness.

Speaker sample: Paula Brumbelow-Burns, Staff.

12 more identified names in Pro: 1 Chair, 2 Staff, 6 Councilmember, 3 Witness.

Full speaker roster in Pro

Meeting audio

Listen to the recording and select a timestamp with Pro.

Audio in Pro

Zoning terms (12)

81 recorded timestamps

  • public hearing (2 timestamps)
  • commercial (12 timestamps)
  • overlay district (4 timestamps)
  • zoning (42 timestamps)
  • residential (9 timestamps)
  • setback (1 timestamps)

Decision moments (8)

Ask this meeting anything

The transcript is ready. Ask questions with answers cited to this meeting in Pro.

Meeting Q&A in Pro

Questions you can ask

  • What conditions were attached to the decisions?
  • What were the recorded votes?
  • Who spoke, and what did they discuss?

Go deeper on this meeting

8 recorded decisions, 1 conditions across 1 decisions. Available full write-ups are included with Pro for Philadelphia.

Full write-up and conditions in Pro

Follow Philadelphia

Get the agenda when a meeting is posted, plus decision and analysis alerts.

We'll email you a 6-digit code, no password.

or