Zoning Board of Adjustment Meeting - 2026-02-23
Meeting Intelligence Preview
Meeting Summary
The Zoning Board of Adjustment approved multiple short-term rental special exceptions, including at 626 Delmar Street Unit 202 (unanimous) and 424 8th Street Units 1-3 (9-1). A mobile food court variance at 602-606 North New Braunfels and 1513 Dawson Street was denied 7-3 for failing to meet the required 200-foot residential separation. The board also approved variances for a multifamily development at 137 University Avenue from NCD-5 standards (10-0) and granted multiple residential fence and carport setback variances throughout the meeting.
Key Decisions (17)
Type 2 STR Special Exception at 626 Delmar Street Unit 202
Rob McLennan granted special exception to allow one additional type 2 short-term rental on block face. Block face currently at 7% with one active type 2 at Unit 201; approval brings it to 13%, exceeding 12.5% density cap. Denver Heights Neighborhood Association in favor.
Type 2 STR Special Exception at 424 8th Street Units 1-3
Skyhawk Custom Homes granted special exception for three additional type 2 STRs. Property originally approved in 2019, permits expired July 2025 due to renewal not submitted. Block face will be at 80% density. Downtown Neighborhood Association did not respond.
Mobile Food Court 200-foot Separation Variance at 602-606 N New Braunfels
Iskander Sehkal denied variance to eliminate required 200-foot separation from residential use for mobile food court on three vacant lots. Applicant proposed 8-10 food trucks. Harvard Place East Lawn and Dignowity Hill Neighborhood Associations in opposition.
Type 2 STR Special Exception at 326 Lexington Avenue Unit 101
Manuel Martinez granted special exception for one additional type 2 STR. Block face has only 2 units total; approval brings density to 100%. Property is designated historic landmark. Downtown Neighbors Association did not respond.
Site Distance Decision Point Variance at 3022 Reforma Drive
Alamo Architects for Southwest ISD granted 2.5-foot variance from 14.5-foot site distance decision point to allow 12-foot decision point at eastern driveway approach. New wrought iron fence installed to comply with TEA security standards encroaches into required sight distance area. Existing speed bump helps mitigate safety concerns.
STR Permit Revocation Appeal at 8201 Meadow Post
JK and France Guidance LLC appeal of administrator's decision to revoke type 2 STR permit continued to March 23. Permit revoked November 18 for failure to report and pay HOT taxes from December 2024 through May 2025. Applicant claims tenant was responsible for STR operations but owner remains liable.
Front Yard Privacy Fence Special Exception at 9310 Magnolia Grove
Saul Gonzales granted 3-foot fence height special exception to allow 6-foot privacy fence on eastern side of front yard, and 5-foot variance for 10-foot driveway clear vision. Fence installed due to ongoing harassment and safety concerns from neighboring tenants. El Centero Neighborhood Association provided no comments.
RM-4 Development Standards Variance at 305-309 Porter Street
Ricardo Navarro granted variance to allow construction of two separate duplex structures on each of three lots instead of single structure per lot. Total 12 dwelling units proposed (four per lot). Denver Heights Neighborhood Association in support. Applicant agreed to limit to two stories per neighborhood request.
Carport Side Setback Variance at 116 East Agarita Avenue
Don b McDonald Architects granted 4-foot 8-inch variance from 5-foot side setback to allow carport with 4-inch setback in rear yard. Carport replaces structure that existed until 1984; will attach to existing two-hour firewall. Monte Vista Historical Neighborhood Association did not respond.
Side Setback Variance at 327 Rainbow Drive
Juan Arceura granted 3-foot 6-inch variance from 5-foot side setback to allow 1-foot 6-inch setback including 1-foot overhang. Structure built on existing carport footprint from 1949 home. Applicant cut back overhang by one foot as requested. Both neighborhood associations in opposition.
Carport and Accessory Structure Variances at 1514 West Salinas Street
Juan Carlos Talavera granted 4-foot 11-inch variance for carport with 1-inch side setback (40 feet depth) and 3-foot 10-inch variance for accessory structure with 1-foot 2-inch setback. Carport constructed without permit; historical imagery shows previous carport removed between 2019-2022. Prospect Hill Neighborhood Association in opposition.
NCD-5 Variances at 137 University Avenue
Mint Development LLC granted three variances from NCD-5 standards: window standard to allow less than 25% glazing on each floor, driveway/curb cut to allow 25-foot driveway and 33-foot curb cut, and attached garages. Development is 22 duplexes (44 units) reduced from originally approved 100-unit project. Beacon Hill Area Neighborhood Association supports items 2 and 3.
Carport Side Setback Variance at 7106 Cloverfield Lane
Albert Trevino granted 4-foot 11-inch variance from 5-foot side setback to allow carport with 1-inch setback. Stop work order issued after construction began without permit. Only posts and concrete footings installed. No registered neighborhood association within 200 feet.
Front Yard Fence Special Exception at 519 North San Marcos
Deborah Wilson granted 1-foot special exception to allow 6-foot predominantly open fence in front yard (5-foot predominantly open permitted by right). Property adjacent to railroad and industrial uses; applicant documented security concerns including individuals looking in windows and climbing existing fence. Gardendale Neighborhood Association in support.
Front Setback and Clear Vision Variances at 143 Globe Avenue
Anna Guerra granted 9-foot 11-inch variance for accessory structure with 1-inch front setback and 5-foot variance for 10-foot driveway clear vision. Carport built without permit; applicant will cut back overhang to comply with property line. University Park Neighborhood Association did not respond.
Lot Layout Variance at 510 Booker Alley
Zigger Architects request for variance to allow primary access from alley for single family lot continued to March 23. Staff recommends denial due to alley width insufficient for emergency vehicles. Dignowity Hill Historic Neighborhood Review Committee opposes request.
Accessory Structure Variance at 11002 Vance Jackson Road
Herman Garuda request for 6,646 square foot variance for maximum 2,500 square foot accessory structure continued to March 9. Staff recommends denial.
Development Activity (3)
Mint Development Multifamily Project
22 duplexes totaling 44 units, three stories, reduced from originally approved 100-unit four-story project. Each unit will have attached garage. Property partially within NCD-5 boundary.
Porter Street Duplexes
12 dwelling units total across three lots (four units per lot), configured as two separate duplex structures per lot. Two-story height committed to neighborhood association.
Southwest ISD School Fence Replacement
Replacement of chain link perimeter fence with wrought iron fence to comply with TEA security standards requiring 6-foot non-climbable fence.
Market Signals (5)
Housing Demand
Multiple short-term rental special exceptions approved despite exceeding density caps, indicating continued investor interest in STR market in San Antonio's urban core.
Housing Demand
Mint Development reduced proposed multifamily project from 100 units to 44 units, suggesting market conditions or financing challenges affecting larger multifamily developments.
Sentiment
Neighborhood associations showing mixed engagement with development proposals; some actively opposing (Dignowity Hill, Prospect Hill) while others supporting or not responding.
Infrastructure
Fire access requirements driving variance requests for driveway widths, with NCD-5's 15-foot curb cut maximum conflicting with 20-foot fire lane requirements for multifamily developments.
Housing Demand
Infill development continuing in Denver Heights and Porter Street areas with support from neighborhood associations for increased density on narrow lots.