Land Use Hearing Officer - 2026-01-12
Meeting Intelligence Preview
Meeting Summary
The Land Use Hearing Officer hearing on January 12, 2026 addressed 12 variance and special use applications in Hillsborough County. Key approvals included a wetland setback variance at 11349 Andy Drive for single-family construction, a two-COP alcoholic beverage permit with distance waivers for La Esquina Sabrosa restaurant at 2730 West Waters Avenue, and a lot split variance at 9912/9916 Alapaya Vista Drive in Gibsonton. Several residential variance requests for porches, screen enclosures, and accessory structures were heard, with decisions to be filed within 15 working days.
Key Decisions (12)
Wetland Setback Variance at 11349 Andy Drive
Eric and LaJoyce Houston requested a 25-foot maximum encroachment into the 30-foot wetland conservation area setback for single-family residential construction, resulting in a 5-foot remaining setback. A wetland setback compensation plan with plantings was provided. No opposition was voiced.
Front Porch Variance at 6802 Rosewood Court
Louisa I Alonzo requested a 6.8-foot variance to the 15-foot front porch setback requirement, resulting in an 8.2-foot setback. An open code compliance violation HCCMP24000134 exists related to the front porch. Town and Country Park Civic Association president Scott Gonzales spoke in opposition, citing pattern of unpermitted construction on the property.
Accessory Structure and Fence Variance at 806 Gateway Lane
Majella Poubles requested an 11-foot variance to the 15-foot front yard setback for an accessory structure (resulting in 4-foot setback) and a 2-foot variance to allow a 6-foot fence in the front yard. The structure is a shed/office for home business use with no kitchen or bathroom. Neighbors Jeff Bishaga and John Lutkus spoke in opposition, alleging the structure resembles a dwelling and that plumbing was installed without permits.
Front Porch Variance at 11905 Bay Tree Drive
Elazar Garza Zapata requested a 5.5-foot variance to the 10-foot front porch projection limit in the AS-1 zoning district, resulting in a 15.5-foot intrusion into the 50-foot required front yard. The porch was already constructed. No opposition was voiced.
Swimming Pool and Patio Variance at 6819 Robbinswood Lane
Kelly Gutierrez requested variances for Osmel Martinez's property: 3-foot variance for screen enclosure side yard (0 feet), 2.2-foot variance for screen enclosure rear yard (0.8 feet), 4.9-foot variance for covered patio side yard (0.1 feet), and 9.1-foot variance for covered patio rear yard (0.9 feet). Two covered areas toward the front of the home have been removed. Easement vacate B250003 was approved.
Lot Split Variance at 9912/9916 Alapaya Vista Drive
Tiffany Lane requested a variance to reduce minimum upland requirements for septic use to allow a lot split. One parcel would have 0.20 acres of upland, the second would have 0.29 acres. Health department approval for septic system was obtained. Property has city water. No opposition was voiced.
Front and Side Yard Variance at 4201 West Hamilton Avenue
Melva Rodriguez requested a 5.14-foot variance to the 25-foot front yard setback (resulting in 19.86 feet) and a 4.68-foot variance to the 7.5-foot side yard setback (resulting in 2.82 feet) for existing structures. The property has a 1950s structure that was remodeled by previous owners. No opposition was voiced.
Rural Scenic Roadway Fence Variance on West Knights Griffin Road
Peter McConaughey (represented by Todd Amadin of Landmark Engineering and builder Chris Torres of Miranda Homes) requested a variance to allow a 6-foot semi-private fence within the 30-foot rural scenic easement for a single-family residential development. Applicant agreed to set fence back 2 feet from easement edge to allow plantings.
Front and Rear Yard Variance at 3905 Americana Drive (Hurricane Helena Rebuild)
Kevin McNamara requested a 1-foot 2.25-inch variance to the 25-foot front yard setback (resulting in 23 feet 7.75 inches) and an 11-foot variance to the 25-foot rear yard setback (resulting in 14 feet) to rebuild his home damaged by Hurricane Helena flooding. The home will be elevated approximately 13 feet above street level with garage underneath. Property is in Dana Shores neighborhood.
Accessory Dwelling and Structure Variance at 6620 Grace Metro
Gautamukumar Ramanini requested an 11-foot variance for accessory dwelling side yard setback (resulting in 4 feet) and a 9-foot variance for accessory structure side yard setback (resulting in 6 feet). Structures were present when property was purchased in July 2024. Code compliance citation HCCMP2500000041 was issued. Staff confirmed accessory dwelling appeared on 2016 aerial and metal shed on 2018 aerial.
Screen Enclosure Roof Variance at 19411 Golden Slipper Place
Gregory La Chapelle and Sharon Gianata requested a 3-foot variance to the 5-foot side yard setback (resulting in 2 feet) to add a solid roof with gutters to existing screen lanai in Traditions at Villa Rosa HOA. HOA approval received 10/17/2025. Neighbor Denise Himes at 4731 Corsage Drive spoke in opposition citing concerns about water runoff, fire hazards, and loss of light.
Two-COP Alcoholic Beverage Permit for La Esquina Sabrosa Restaurant
Maria Rodriguez (represented by Terry Haley) requested a two-COP beer and wine permit for La Esquina Sabrosa restaurant at 2730 West Waters Avenue with distance waivers: residential separation reduced from 250 feet to 126.2 feet, Oak Grove United Methodist Church separation reduced from 500 feet to 184 feet, and Faith Baptist Church separation reduced from 500 feet to 384 feet. Wet zone footprint of 2,762 square feet. Staff recommended approval. No opposition was voiced.
Development Activity (4)
Single-Family Residence at 11349 Andy Drive
New single-family home construction requiring 25-foot encroachment into 30-foot wetland conservation area setback with 5-foot remaining setback and compensation plantings
Miranda Homes Subdivision on West Knights Griffin Road
Single-family residential subdivision with 150-foot minimum lot depth, 30-foot rural scenic buffer easement, turn lane dedication, and 6-foot semi-private perimeter fence set back 2 feet for plantings
Hurricane Helena Rebuild at 3905 Americana Drive
Complete rebuild of flood-damaged home elevated approximately 13 feet above street level with garage underneath, same footprint as existing structure including 1994 room addition
Lot Split at 9912/9916 Alapaya Vista Drive
Lot split to create buildable parcel of approximately 8,000 square feet for single-family home construction with septic system approved by health department
Market Signals (5)
Housing Demand
Hurricane Helena flood damage in Dana Shores neighborhood is driving home rebuilds with significant elevation requirements (13+ feet above street level), indicating continued residential investment despite flood risk.
Housing Demand
Property owners are seeking variances to maximize lot utilization through lot splits and accessory dwelling units, suggesting strong demand for additional housing inventory in established neighborhoods.
Commercial Demand
Existing restaurant at busy West Waters Avenue and Havana intersection seeking beer and wine license after 1.5 years of operation indicates customer demand for enhanced dining amenities in commercial corridors.
Infrastructure
Rural scenic roadway requirements on West Knights Griffin Road include turn lane dedications, 19-foot drainage ditches, and 5-foot sidewalks, indicating infrastructure investment in developing areas.
Sentiment
Neighborhood opposition to accessory structures and unpermitted construction in Town and Country Park area reflects community concerns about maintaining single-family residential character.